Dishwasher or Hand Washing: Which Uses Less Water?

dishwasher vs washing dishes by hand water use

Torn over dishwasher vs washing dishes by hand water use? A full dishwasher usually uses less water than typical hand washing, though your habits decide it. Here is how to tell.

This guide is one part of the wider topic of how to save water at home.

Item Reported value
Hand washing, average per person per day 10.5 liters (2.77 gallons)
Best Electrolux dishwashers (maker’s claim), per person per day 2.27 liters
Average full dishwasher cycle About 15 liters (4 gallons)
Most efficient dishwasher per cycle (Greener Choices report) 11.3 liters (3 gallons)
Share of dishwasher energy used to heat the water About 80%
London’s modelled saving if every household used a dishwasher 16 billion liters a year

The figures come from a New Atlas report of April 7, 2009 and a Rise guide to washing dishes. Figures can change, so check the sources before you rely on them.

How the numbers compare

The New Atlas report describes a study based on findings from the University of Bonn in Germany. It puts hand washing at an average of 10.5 liters (2.77 gallons) of water per person per day for the normal amount of dishes, as New Atlas reported.

The same report says Electrolux claims its best dishwashers use only 2.27 liters for the same dishes per person per day. It also says those Electrolux models were not included in the study, so treat the figure as a manufacturer’s claim.

The study used population data from 22 European countries and sorted hand washing into three habits:

  • Washing in a bowl or the sink.
  • Washing under running water.
  • A combination of both.

Why per-person and per-cycle figures differ

Dishwasher figures are usually given per cycle, while the hand-washing average is per person per day. According to the same report, a full dishwasher cycle uses about 15 liters (4 gallons) on average.

A Greener Choices report cited there puts the most efficient water-saving dishwasher at 11.3 liters (3 gallons) per cycle. That makes load size the swing factor: one full cycle covers many dishes, while a part-empty one spreads the same water over fewer.

The study also estimates that London alone could save as much as 16 billion liters of fresh water a year if every household used a dishwasher instead of washing by hand, per New Atlas. Treat that as a modelled estimate from a maker, not a measurement of your own kitchen.

Where does the energy go?

Water is only half the story, because heating it takes energy. Rise says about 80% of the energy used by most dishwashers goes solely to heating the wash water.

Eco or energy-saving cycles, Rise adds, clean just as effectively while reducing the water temperature and the amount of water used. The New Atlas report makes a related point: a machine that needs less water also needs less energy to heat it.

Your manual will tell you whether your machine has an eco cycle. Rise notes many owners never notice one.

Habits that decide the winner

Both sources point to the same few habits, and most of them come down to how you load and run the machine.

  1. Run full loads. Rise advises waiting until the machine is full, without overfilling it, since dishes may rattle against each other and break.
  2. Scrape, don’t rinse. Rise says pre-rinsing uses a great deal of extra water, and a scrape into the compost bin plus a quick wipe of any sauce is enough.
  3. Look for a half-load setting. Without one, the machine uses the same energy and water however few dishes are inside.
  4. Let dishes air dry. Rise suggests the air-dry option instead of the heat-dry setting, or leaving the door open once the wash ends.

The New Atlas report adds that most people use less than half of the possible space inside their dishwasher, and that fuller loads would save a lot more water. It also lists changing to a modern dishwasher every few years, as appliances become more efficient over time.

A kitchen sink sits beneath a wide window overlooking greenery.

Limits of the figures and how to test your own

The report itself calls the average hand-washing figures debatable, since they depend on how conscious you are of water use at the sink. It also flags that the study was presented by Electrolux, a company that makes washing machines, per New Atlas.

Others noted that the energy embodied in building a dishwasher may not have been taken into account. Because the report dates from 2009, newer machines may differ, so check your own model’s rated water use.

A practical test is to learn how to read a water meter and compare readings across a day of each method. Laundry raises a similar choice, and the guide to a water efficient washing machine covers it.

Frequently asked questions

Does a dishwasher really use less water than washing by hand?

Show answer

In the reported figures, a full, efficient machine beats the typical hand-washing average. The result shifts with how you wash at the sink and how full you run the machine, and the headline numbers come from a study presented by a manufacturer.

Should I rinse plates before loading them?

Show answer

Not as a rule. The New Atlas report says a scrape is all modern machines need, and rinsing first adds water you did not have to use.

Is it wasteful to run a half-empty dishwasher?

Show answer

It can be. According to Rise, a machine without a half-load setting draws the same energy and water whatever the load, so waiting for a full rack saves resources.

Is air drying better than the heat-dry setting?

Show answer

Rise recommends air drying where possible, with a suitable detergent and rinse aid. If your machine has no air-dry setting, it suggests opening the door after the cycle and leaving it open overnight.